10 Best Alternatives to Tulsa Body Jewelry for Stylish and Safe Piercings

Welcome to the ultimate guide for body jewelry enthusiasts who want to explore options beyond Tulsa Body Jewelry. If you love expressing yourself through piercings but are looking for variety, quality, and value, you have arrived at the right place.

Our carefully researched list features reputable retailers that offer exceptional selections of body jewelry to suit every style preference and budget.

In a Nutshell:

Before diving into our detailed reviews, here are some essential points to remember when shopping for body jewelry:

• Material matters for your health and comfort. Implant-grade titanium and 316L surgical steel are two of the most biocompatible materials for body jewelry, reducing risks of allergic reactions and irritation.
• The gauge size (thickness) of your jewelry must match your piercing to avoid discomfort and migration. Never force jewelry that feels too large.
• Quality certifications like those from the Association of Professional Piercers indicate trusted manufacturers who follow strict production standards.
• Higher prices often reflect better materials and craftsmanship, making premium jewelry a worthwhile investment for frequently worn pieces.
• Customer reviews provide valuable insights about actual wear experience, shipping reliability, and customer service quality.
• Return policies vary significantly between retailers; always check before purchasing, especially for custom or intimate items.
• Internal threading is preferable to external threading for most piercings as it causes less trauma when inserting jewelry.
• Starter jewelry should always be made from high-quality materials to promote proper healing and reduce complications.
• Many body jewelry retailers offer both budget-friendly basics and statement pieces, allowing you to build a diverse collection.
• Regular cleaning of your body jewelry extends its lifespan and protects your piercings from infection.

BodyArtForms – Sister-Owned Body Jewelry Paradise

BodyArtForms stands as one of the most respected names in the body jewelry industry. Since 2001, this sister-owned business has built a reputation for offering an extensive selection of quality body jewelry at competitive prices.

Features:

• Enormous selection spanning from basic studs to exotic handmade pieces
• Clear material labeling with separate sections for implant-grade jewelry
• Detailed product specifications including exact measurements
• Reward points system for frequent shoppers
• Regular sales and clearance events

Pros:

• Verification program that ensures authentic products from top manufacturers
• Exceptional customer service with knowledgeable staff
• Fast shipping with tracking on all orders
• Transparent about materials and manufacturing
• Carries both affordable and high-end options

Cons:

• Website can feel overwhelming to new shoppers
• Popular items sell out quickly and may have long restock times
• Some budget items are lower quality than described
• International shipping can be expensive

What makes BodyArtForms truly exceptional is their commitment to education, providing detailed information about materials and piercing care alongside their products. Their reward system also makes it worthwhile to become a regular customer, with points accumulating toward future purchases.

Urban Body Jewelry – Modern Designs With Affordable Options

Urban Body Jewelry has become a go-to source for people seeking contemporary jewelry designs at accessible price points. Their product range focuses on trendy pieces while maintaining quality standards.

Features:

• Extensive collection of plugs and tunnels in unique designs
• User-friendly website with helpful filtering options
• Detailed size charts and measurement guides
• Weekly new arrivals and seasonal collections
• Impressive selection of anodized titanium in various colors

Pros:

• Very competitive pricing on most items
• Frequent sales and promotions
• Fast shipping within the continental US
• Good selection of internally threaded jewelry
• Responsive customer service team

Cons:

• Quality can be inconsistent across different product lines
• Limited high-end designer options
• Some plated items may show wear quickly
• Return process can be complicated

Urban Body Jewelry excels at providing trendy designs that won’t break the bank. Their selection of colorful anodized titanium jewelry is particularly impressive, offering safe options for those with metal sensitivities who still want vibrant jewelry.

Anatometal – Premium American-Made Body Jewelry

For those seeking the absolute best in quality and craftsmanship, Anatometal represents the gold standard in American-made body jewelry. Founded over 30 years ago, this company has pioneered many of the safety standards that define quality body jewelry today.

Features:

• Exclusively made in the USA under strict quality control
• Lifetime guarantee on most products
• Implant-grade materials (ASTM F136 titanium and ASTM F138 steel)
• Custom gem setting and specialized designs
• Internally threaded for comfort and safety

Pros:

• Exceptional polishing and finishing details
• Gems are hand-set and guaranteed not to fall out
• Hypoallergenic materials safe for sensitive individuals
• Precisely machined threads that don’t strip or cross-thread
• Uncompromising quality standards

Cons:

• Higher price point than many competitors
• Limited availability through authorized retailers only
• Custom orders can take several weeks to complete
• Fewer trendy or novelty designs
• Minimal direct-to-consumer sales

Anatometal’s dedication to precision manufacturing and implant-grade materials has made them a favorite among professional piercers worldwide. While their products command premium prices, the quality difference is immediately noticeable in both appearance and comfort.

Diablo Body Jewelry – Unique Artistic Creations

Diablo Body Jewelry specializes in artistic, handcrafted pieces that stand out from mass-produced options. Their focus on unique designs makes them perfect for those seeking statement jewelry.

Features:

• Hand-crafted organic materials (stone, wood, bone)
• Artistic one-of-a-kind designs
• Collaborations with independent artists
• Custom sizing available for many items
• Specialized in stretched ear jewelry

Pros:

• Truly unique pieces not found elsewhere
• Strong ethical sourcing policies
• Expert craftsmanship with attention to detail
• Excellent photography showing true colors and patterns
• Knowledgeable staff familiar with custom work

Cons:

• Higher price point reflecting handmade quality
• Limited selection of basic jewelry
• Longer processing times for custom orders
• Organic materials require special care
• Fewer options for standard piercings

Diablo’s artisanal approach creates jewelry that doubles as wearable art. Their hand-carved plugs and stone inlay work show exceptional craftsmanship that mass-produced items cannot match. For special occasions or statement pieces, Diablo offers something truly distinctive.

Body Circle Designs – Sleek Minimalist Jewelry

No products found.

Body Circle Designs has carved out a niche with their sleek, minimalist approach to body jewelry. Their clean lines and modern aesthetic appeal particularly to professionals who want subtle yet high-quality pieces.

Features:

• Streamlined, professional-friendly designs
• Focus on high-polish finish titanium and steel
• Precision machined threading systems
• Interchangeable components
• Specializes in discreet, workplace-appropriate options

Pros:

• Exceptional comfort for everyday wear
• Minimalist designs that complement any style
• Consistent sizing across product lines
• High mirror polish that resists tarnishing
• Excellent for healing piercings due to smooth finish

Cons:

• Limited decorative or statement pieces
• Fewer color options than some competitors
• Less frequent new product releases
• Higher price point than basic jewelry
• Minimal options for organic materials

Body Circle excels in creating understated elegance through perfect execution of simple designs. Their attention to comfort makes these pieces ideal for long-term wear, while the clean aesthetic works well in professional environments where subtle body jewelry is preferred.

Neometal – Innovative Threading Technology

Neometal revolutionized the body jewelry industry with their proprietary threadless jewelry system, providing secure wearability without the typical complications of threaded jewelry.

Features:

• Patented threadless technology
• Implant-grade materials (ASTM F136 titanium)
• Interchangeable ends and posts
• Low-profile designs for comfortable wear
• Exceptional gem setting quality

Pros:

• Highly secure; ends won’t unscrew or fall out
• Easier insertion than traditional threaded jewelry
• Smooth components reduce irritation
• Customizable with mix-and-match components
• Smaller end options than most competitors

Cons:

• Learning curve for adjusting pin tension
• Special tools recommended for installation
• Limited availability through authorized dealers
• Premium pricing reflects patented technology
• Fewer statement or large-scale designs

Neometal’s innovative approach to secure, comfortable jewelry has made them extremely popular for everyday wear pieces, especially in ear cartilage piercings. The ability to easily change decorative ends while keeping the post in place is particularly valuable for healing or difficult-to-reach piercings.

BVLA (Body Vision Los Angeles) – Luxury Body Jewelry

When only the most exquisite body jewelry will do, BVLA stands as the uncontested leader in luxury pieces. Specializing in solid gold and platinum with genuine gemstones, BVLA creates heirloom-quality body jewelry.

Features:

• Solid 14k and 18k gold (yellow, white, rose)
• Genuine diamonds and precious gemstones
• Custom design services available
• Intricate handcrafted details
• Lifetime warranty against manufacturing defects

Pros:

• Unparalleled craftsmanship and artistry
• Investment-quality materials with lasting value
• Hypoallergenic options for extremely sensitive individuals
• Exclusive, limited-edition designs
• Status symbol among body jewelry enthusiasts

Cons:

• Premium luxury pricing
• Extended lead times for custom pieces
• Limited availability through authorized retailers
• Requires special care and cleaning
• Insurance recommended for higher-value pieces

BVLA creates jaw-dropping statement pieces that transcend typical body jewelry to become true fine jewelry. Their use of solid gold and genuine gemstones makes these pieces investment purchases that will last a lifetime with proper care.

Industrial Strength – Durable Everyday Jewelry

As the name suggests, Industrial Strength focuses on creating exceptionally durable body jewelry designed to withstand daily wear. Their robust construction makes them ideal for active lifestyles.

Features:

• Implant-grade materials built to last
• Specialized in larger gauge jewelry
• Extra-secure threading and connections
• Precision machined components
• Industrial aesthetic with clean lines

Pros:

• Exceptional durability even with rough handling
• Consistency in sizing across product lines
• Good selection of larger gauge options
• Secure gem settings resist loosening
• Excellent for long-term wear

Cons:

• Utilitarian designs may lack decorative elements
• Heavier than some competing brands
• Limited color options beyond anodized titanium
• Higher price point than basic jewelry
• Less frequent introduction of new designs

Industrial Strength’s focus on durability without compromising safety makes them particularly popular among active people who need jewelry that can withstand physical activities. Their larger-gauge barbells and rings are especially well-regarded in the body modification community.

Starfire Body Jewelry – Curated Collection of Premium Brands

Rather than manufacturing their own line, Starfire Body Jewelry has built a reputation as a trusted curator of premium body jewelry brands. Their expert selection process ensures quality across their diverse offerings.

Features:

• Carefully vetted selection of top brands
• Excellent photography and product descriptions
• Educational content about materials and sizing
• Professional piercer consultation available
• Regular introduction of new brands and products

Pros:

• One-stop shopping for multiple premium brands
• Consistent quality standards across all products
• Exceptional customer service from knowledgeable staff
• Transparent about material specifications
• Good stock levels of popular items

Cons:

• Premium pricing reflects high-end brand selection
• Limited budget options compared to larger retailers
• Smaller overall selection than some competitors
• Shipping times vary based on stock status
• Return policies vary by brand

Starfire excels at thoughtful curation, bringing together the best pieces from multiple manufacturers. Their commitment to education and transparency makes them particularly valuable for those new to quality body jewelry who want guidance from experts.

Infinite Body Piercing – Professional Piercer Standards

Infinite Body originated as a professional piercing studio and has grown to offer an online selection that mirrors what professional piercers recommend. Their focus on safety and quality makes them ideal for those prioritizing piercing health.

Features:

• Curated selection meeting professional standards
• Detailed information about materials and safety
• Focus on jewelry appropriate for healing piercings
• Professional piercing advice and aftercare information
• Carries only brands approved by the Association of Professional Piercers

Pros:

• Everything meets minimum safety standards
• Expert staff with professional piercing experience
• Excellent resource for troubleshooting problem piercings
• Clear information about appropriate jewelry types
• Maintains stock of sizes for less common piercings

Cons:

• More limited selection than larger retailers
• Higher average price point
• Fewer decorative or novelty options
• Limited budget-friendly choices
• Longer shipping times during busy seasons

Infinite Body stands out for their unwavering commitment to safety and proper jewelry selection. Their background as professional piercers informs every aspect of their business, making them especially valuable for those with healing or problematic piercings.

Frequently Asked Questions

What materials are safest for body jewelry?

The safest materials for body jewelry are implant-grade titanium (ASTM F136), implant-grade surgical steel (ASTM F138), 14k or 18k solid gold, niobium, and glass. These materials minimize risk of allergic reactions and are suitable for long-term wear.

How do I know what gauge my piercing is?

Most standard earlobe piercings are 20g or 18g. Newer piercings done at professional studios typically use 16g or 14g. The best way to determine your exact gauge is to consult your piercer or use a gauge wheel to compare with jewelry you know fits comfortably.

Can I develop an allergy to my body jewelry over time?

Yes. Metal sensitivities can develop with repeated exposure, particularly to nickel, which is present in many lower-quality metals. If you notice increasing irritation with jewelry you’ve worn before, you may be developing a sensitivity.

How often should I clean my body jewelry?

Body jewelry should be cleaned whenever you remove it. For everyday wear, a weekly cleaning is sufficient. Healing piercings require more frequent cleaning according to your piercer’s instructions.

Is titanium jewelry worth the higher price?

For many people, especially those with sensitive skin or metal allergies, titanium is absolutely worth the investment. It’s lightweight, highly biocompatible, and resists corrosion, making it comfortable for long-term wear.

Can I wear surgical steel if I have a nickel allergy?

Most people with mild nickel allergies can wear high-quality implant-grade surgical steel (ASTM F138). However, those with severe nickel allergies should choose titanium, niobium, or solid gold instead.