4 Best Alternatives to Rothy’s Shoes

Rothy’s shoes have earned a devoted following thanks to their sustainable design, comfort, and sleek style.

Made from recycled plastic bottles, these knit flats are eco-friendly, machine-washable, and versatile.

Below, I’ve rounded up four standout products that echo Rothy’s appeal while offering unique features of their own. Each comes with detailed features, pros, and cons to help you find the perfect fit.

Skechers Women’s Cleo Ballet Flat

This ballet flat from Skechers mirrors Rothy’s knit aesthetic with a stretchy, breathable upper made from soft fabric. It features a cushioned memory foam insole for all-day comfort and a flexible rubber outsole for traction.

Available in multiple colors, it’s also machine-washable, making it a practical choice for busy lifestyles. The design includes a subtle pointed toe, adding a touch of elegance similar to Rothy’s The Point.

Pros

• Affordable Comfort: The memory foam insole provides excellent cushioning, rivaling Rothy’s comfort at a lower cost.
• Washable: Like Rothy’s, these flats can go in the washing machine, keeping them fresh with minimal effort.
• Versatile Style: The sleek design pairs well with casual or professional outfits.
• Breathable: The knit upper promotes airflow, reducing sweat during long wear.

Cons

• Break-In Period: Some users report the shoes feel snug initially, requiring time to stretch out.
• Less Sustainable: Unlike Rothy’s recycled materials, these don’t emphasize eco-friendly production.
• Durability Concerns: The fabric may wear faster with heavy use compared to Rothy’s knit.

VIVAIA Women’s Square-Toe Mary Jane Flat

VIVAIA brings a sustainable twist to this alternative, crafting the upper from recycled plastic bottles, much like Rothy’s. This square-toe Mary Jane flat features a natural latex insole for cushioning and arch support, plus a carbon-free rubber outsole for durability.

It’s lightweight, foldable for travel, and spot-cleanable (though not fully machine-washable). The chic strap design adds a distinctive flair.

Pros

• Eco-Friendly: Made with recycled materials, it aligns with Rothy’s sustainability ethos.
• Supportive: The latex insole offers better arch support than Rothy’s, ideal for those with foot issues.
• Stylish Design: The square toe and strap elevate the look, perfect for dressing up.
• Portable: Its foldable nature makes it a great travel companion.

Cons

• Not Fully Washable: Spot-cleaning only limits its convenience compared to Rothy’s machine-washable feature.
• Fit Variability: Runs narrow, so wider feet may need to size up.
• Price: While cheaper than Rothy’s, it’s still a moderate investment.

Naturalizer Women’s Flexy Ballet Flat

The Naturalizer Flexy Ballet Flat offers a classic round-toe silhouette reminiscent of Rothy’s The Flat. It features a soft textile upper, a cushioned footbed with arch support, and a lightweight, flexible sole.

Available in various colors and patterns, this flat prioritizes comfort with a roomy toe box and durable construction, though it’s not machine-washable.

Pros

• Superior Comfort: The cushioned footbed and arch support make it ideal for all-day wear.
• Roomy Fit: The wider toe box suits those who find Rothy’s too tapered.
• Durable: Built to last longer than some knit alternatives with regular use.
• Affordable: A budget-friendly option without sacrificing quality.

Cons

• Not Washable: Requires spot-cleaning, lacking Rothy’s easy-care appeal.
• Less Breathable: The textile upper isn’t as airy as Rothy’s knit fabric.
• Basic Style: Lacks the modern, knit look that defines Rothy’s aesthetic.

Slocyclub Women’s Knit Loafer Flat

This knit loafer flat from Slocyclub closely mimics Rothy’s The Driver with its slip-on design and knit upper. It includes a memory foam insole for cushioning, a non-slip rubber sole, and a foldable structure for easy packing.

Available in a range of colors, it’s machine-washable and lightweight, making it a strong contender for Rothy’s fans seeking a loafer style.

Pros

• Rothy’s-Like Design: The knit upper and slip-on style echo Rothy’s signature look.
• Washable: Toss it in the machine for hassle-free cleaning.
• Budget-Friendly: Significantly less expensive than Rothy’s loafers.
• Comfortable: Memory foam adds plush support for daily wear.

Cons

• Sustainability Unknown: No clear mention of recycled materials, unlike Rothy’s eco-focus.
• Sizing Issues: Some report inconsistent fit, so checking size charts is key.
• Less Polished: The design feels slightly less refined than Rothy’s premium finish.

Final Thoughts

If you’re drawn to Rothy’s for their sustainability and style but need a more accessible price point or different features, these alternatives deliver.

The Skechers Cleo Ballet Flat is a washable, budget-friendly pick for everyday wear. VIVAIA’s Square-Toe Mary Jane Flat shines with eco-conscious design and support. The Naturalizer Flexy Ballet Flat offers durability and comfort for wider feet, while the Slocyclub Knit Loafer Flat nails the loafer vibe at a fraction of the cost.

Each brings something unique to the table—whether it’s affordability, support, or portability—so you can step into style without breaking the bank. Which one fits your vibe?