7 Best Alternatives To Memery Shoes: Vintage Style With Modern Comfort

Are you in love with the timeless elegance of vintage footwear but struggling to find quality alternatives to Memery Shoes?

The perfect vintage-inspired shoe combines historical authenticity with modern comfort and wearability.

Memery Shoes has built a reputation for crafting beautiful full-grain leather shoes inspired by designs from the 1900s to 1960s, but they can be expensive and sometimes hard to find in stock.

In a Nutshell

Before diving into each alternative, here are the key takeaways about what makes a great Memery Shoes alternative:

• Quality Materials: The best alternatives use premium leathers that soften and mold to your feet over time, just like Memery’s full-grain leather construction
• Authentic Design: Look for shoes that stay true to vintage aesthetics with period-correct details like wing tips, perforations, and proper heel shapes
• Modern Comfort: Great alternatives combine vintage style with modern comfort features like padded insoles and flexible construction
• Size Inclusivity: Many alternatives offer extended size ranges and width options to fit more feet than standard vintage shoes
• Craftsmanship: Quality stitching, solid construction, and attention to detail ensure your vintage-style shoes will last for years
• Value: While some alternatives are premium-priced, others offer excellent quality at more accessible price points
• Versatility: The best vintage-inspired shoes work with both period-accurate clothing and modern wardrobes
• Care Requirements: Full-grain leather shoes require proper maintenance to look their best, so consider the upkeep commitment
• Sole Construction: Look for shoes with leather soles for authenticity or rubber soles for durability and wet conditions
• Breaking-in Period: Quality leather shoes typically need time to conform to your feet, so patience may be required

Let’s explore the seven best alternatives to Memery Shoes that offer that perfect blend of vintage charm and modern wearability!

Eastland Women’s Sadie Oxford: The Classic Saddle Shoe

The Eastland Women’s Sadie Oxford brings timeless 1950s style to your wardrobe with its iconic black and white saddle design. This shoe captures the essence of mid-century fashion while incorporating modern comfort features that make it wearable all day.

Features

• Crafted from premium leather with the classic two-tone saddle design
• Features Eastland’s exclusive Active Memory Foam comfort insole that supports and conforms to your foot
• Breathable fabric lining keeps feet comfortable
• Supportive shank reduces foot and leg fatigue during extended wear
• Super-lightweight rubber outsole offers excellent traction and durability
• 6/8″ heel height provides a subtle lift without sacrificing stability

Pros

• Memory foam insole makes these significantly more comfortable than traditional vintage shoes
• Available in multiple width options to accommodate different foot shapes
• Durable construction ensures long-lasting wear
• The classic design pairs well with both vintage and contemporary outfits
• Lower price point than Memery Shoes while maintaining quality construction

Cons

• Some users report needing to size down for a proper fit
• The leather upper can be stiff initially and requires breaking in
• The tongue may rub on the top of the foot until softened
• Not as historically accurate in some details as Memery Shoes

The Eastland Sadie Oxford is perfect for anyone wanting an authentic-looking saddle shoe that doesn’t sacrifice comfort. These shoes work beautifully with 1950s-inspired circle skirts or vintage dresses, but they’re equally at home with modern jeans or trousers.

At a substantially lower price point than Memery Shoes, they offer excellent value while maintaining quality.

Erocalli Women’s Mary Jane Pumps: Heart-Stopping Vintage Charm

For those who adore the Mary Jane style that was popular in the 1920s through 1950s, the Erocalli Women’s Mary Jane Pumps deliver beautiful vintage-inspired details with a unique heart cutout design that sets them apart.

Features

• Adorable heart hollow design adds unique vintage flair
• Chunky 2.5-inch block heel provides stability and period-accurate styling
• Round toe design offers comfort and authentic vintage aesthetics
• Comes in multiple colors including black, brown, green, red, and camel
• Lace-up design allows for a custom fit
• Synthetic upper with a classic silhouette

Pros

• The heart cutout detail adds a distinctive vintage touch not found in most alternatives
• Block heel provides stability while maintaining authentic period style
• The lace closure allows for adjustability to fit different foot widths
• Multiple color options let you match with different vintage outfits
• Very affordable compared to Memery Shoes

Cons

• Made with synthetic materials rather than full-grain leather
• Some users report a strong chemical smell when new
• Mixed reviews on sizing consistency
• Less durable construction than premium leather alternatives

The Erocalli Mary Janes are ideal for anyone wanting a vintage-inspired statement shoe at an accessible price point. Their unique heart cutout makes them stand out from more standard designs.

They work particularly well for costuming, themed events, or adding a touch of vintage charm to everyday outfits without breaking the bank.

SHEMEE Women’s Wingtip Oxfords: Sophisticated Vintage Brogues

The SHEMEE Wingtip Oxfords channel the sophisticated working woman’s style of the 1930s and 1940s with authentic brogue detailing and sturdy construction. These shoes are perfect for those who appreciate the more practical side of vintage fashion.

Features

• Classic wingtip brogue design with authentic perforations
• Chunky 2.56″ stacked block heel provides stability and height
• Round toe design offers comfort and period-accurate styling
• Synthetic upper with vintage-inspired detailing
• Rubber sole combines period appearance with modern durability
• Available in multiple colors including brown, black, and gray

Pros

• Historically accurate wingtip detailing captures true vintage aesthetic
• The stacked heel has an authentic vintage appearance
• Available in a wide range of sizes (4-11) and colors
• Comfortable for all-day wear according to most reviewers
• Price point is significantly lower than premium vintage reproductions

Cons

• Synthetic materials rather than full-grain leather
• Some reviewers note durability concerns with extended use
• May run slightly large according to some customers
• Requires occasional leather care to maintain appearance

The SHEMEE Wingtip Oxfords are perfect for achieving a sophisticated 1930s or 1940s look, particularly when paired with vintage-inspired trousers or skirts.

Their versatile design works well for both office wear and special occasions, making them a practical addition to a vintage-inspired wardrobe. The detailed brogue work gives them an authentically vintage appearance at a fraction of the price of true reproductions.

American Duchess Historical Footwear: Museum-Quality Reproductions

For those seeking the most historically accurate vintage reproductions without compromise, American Duchess offers meticulously researched and crafted historical footwear spanning multiple eras, from the 18th century through the 1950s.

Features

• Historically accurate designs based on extensive research of vintage originals
• Premium leather construction with proper period techniques
• Available in a range of styles from different historical eras
• Many styles feature leather soles for authentic period appearance and feel
• Designed specifically for historical costumers, reenactors, and vintage enthusiasts
• Proper period heel shapes and toe designs

Pros

• Unmatched historical accuracy in design and construction
• Exceptional quality materials and craftsmanship
• Extensive range of styles covering multiple historical periods
• Many styles available in hard-to-find wide sizes
• Company founded and run by historical costume experts

Cons

• Premium price point (typically $150-300)
• Limited availability of some styles due to small production runs
• May require more breaking in than modern shoes
• Primarily designed for historical authenticity rather than modern comfort

American Duchess shoes represent the gold standard in historical footwear reproduction. While they come at a premium price, they offer unmatched authenticity for historical costumers, reenactors, or those who demand the most accurate vintage appearance.

Their shoes are particularly valued for their correct silhouettes and construction methods that closely mirror original vintage footwear.

Re-Mix Vintage Shoes: Hollywood’s Vintage Footwear Secret

Re-Mix Vintage Shoes has earned a cult following among vintage enthusiasts and Hollywood costume departments alike for their faithful reproductions of classic 1920s-1950s footwear styles with exceptional quality.

Features

• Handcrafted in Los Angeles using traditional methods
• Designs based on original vintage shoes from the 1920s-1950s
• Full-grain leather uppers with leather or leather-topped rubber soles
• Wide range of styles including oxfords, pumps, sandals, and wedges
• Many styles available in hard-to-find sizes
• Frequently used in period films and television productions

Pros

• Exceptional quality and attention to historical detail
• Handmade in the USA using traditional construction methods
• Extensive range of historically accurate designs
• Superior materials and craftsmanship
• Many styles feature combination leather/rubber soles for better durability

Cons

• Premium price point (typically $190-300)
• Limited retail availability (primarily sold through their website)
• Minimal modern comfort features in most styles
• May require professional care and maintenance

Re-Mix Vintage Shoes offers some of the most authentic vintage reproductions available today, particularly for styles from the 1930s through 1950s. Their shoes are prized by serious vintage enthusiasts and professional costumers for their accurate styling and quality construction. While their price point is similar to Memery Shoes, they offer an American-made alternative with exceptional craftsmanship.

Charlie Stone Shoes: Vintage Flats With Modern Comfort

For those who love vintage style but prefer a lower heel height, Charlie Stone Shoes specializes in vintage-inspired flats and low heels that combine period aesthetics with all-day wearability.

Features

• Vintage-inspired designs from the 1920s through 1950s
• Many styles feature a hidden low wedge for comfort
• Soft leather uppers with cushioned insoles
• Wide selection of T-straps, Mary Janes, and Oxford styles
• Available in a variety of colors and finishes
• Focus on everyday wearability with vintage appeal

Pros

• Exceptionally comfortable for everyday wear
• Hidden wedge provides support without sacrificing vintage appearance
• More affordable than many premium reproduction brands
• Soft leather requires minimal breaking in
• Versatile styles work with both vintage and modern wardrobes

Cons

• Less historically accurate than some premium alternatives
• Limited availability in some regions
• Primarily focused on flats and low heels rather than period-correct higher heels
• Some styles sell out quickly and aren’t restocked regularly

Charlie Stone Shoes excel at creating vintage-inspired footwear that’s comfortable enough for daily wear. Their focus on flats and low heels makes them particularly appealing to those who want vintage style without sacrificing comfort.

Their hidden wedge construction provides support while maintaining a period-appropriate silhouette, making them a practical alternative to Memery Shoes for everyday vintage style.

Ellie Shoes Women’s Saddle Oxford: Budget-Friendly Vintage Style

For those seeking vintage flair at the most accessible price point, the Ellie Shoes Saddle Oxford delivers classic 1950s style without breaking the bank.

Features

• Classic black and white saddle oxford design
• 1-inch heel height for authentic vintage proportion
• Synthetic materials with vintage-inspired styling
• Lace-up closure for adjustable fit
• Available in various color combinations
• Lightweight construction

Pros

• Most affordable option for vintage-inspired saddle shoes
• Classic styling works well for costumes and casual vintage looks
• Lightweight and comfortable out of the box
• No breaking-in period required
• Available in fun color combinations beyond traditional black and white

Cons

• Synthetic materials rather than leather
• Less durable than premium alternatives
• Limited comfort features
• Sizing can be inconsistent according to some reviewers
• Less historically accurate details than premium brands

The Ellie Shoes Saddle Oxford provides a budget-friendly way to achieve a vintage look, particularly for costume purposes or occasional wear. While they lack the quality materials and construction of premium alternatives, they deliver recognizable vintage style at a fraction of the price.

These are ideal for those just beginning to explore vintage fashion or who need period-appropriate shoes for specific events without a significant investment.

How To Choose The Right Memery Shoes Alternative

When selecting an alternative to Memery Shoes, consider these important factors:

Style Period: Different brands excel at different eras. American Duchess and Re-Mix offer the most historically accurate options across multiple periods, while other brands may focus on specific decades.

Material Quality: Full-grain leather offers the best durability and develops a beautiful patina over time, but requires more maintenance. Synthetic alternatives are more affordable but typically less durable.

Comfort Needs: Consider whether you need shoes primarily for looks or for extended wear. Brands like Charlie Stone and Eastland incorporate more modern comfort features.

Budget: Prices range from under $40 for budget options to over $250 for premium reproductions. Determine your budget before shopping.

Sizing: Many vintage-inspired shoes run differently from modern sizes. Always check size charts and read reviews about fit before purchasing.

Occasion: For everyday wear, consider options with more comfort features and durability. For special occasions or historical accuracy, premium reproductions may be worth the investment.

Caring For Your Vintage-Style Shoes

To extend the life of your vintage-inspired footwear:

1. Rotate Your Shoes: Allow at least 24 hours between wearings to let leather shoes dry completely.
2. Use Shoe Trees: Cedar shoe trees help maintain shape and absorb moisture.
3. Clean Regularly: Wipe leather shoes with a damp cloth to remove dirt, then condition with an appropriate leather conditioner.
4. Protect From Water: Treat leather shoes with a water-repellent spray, particularly if they have leather soles.
5. Replace Heels and Soles: When heels or soles show significant wear, have them replaced by a professional cobbler before damage extends to the upper.
6. Store Properly: Keep shoes in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight to prevent leather from drying and cracking.

Why Choose Vintage-Style Shoes?

Vintage-inspired footwear offers several advantages over both modern designs and actual vintage shoes:

• Timeless Style: Vintage designs have proven their staying power and never look dated.
• Quality Construction: Many vintage-inspired shoes use traditional construction methods that are more durable than modern fast fashion.
• Versatility: Classic vintage styles complement both period-accurate and contemporary outfits.
• Better Fit: Reproduction vintage shoes offer historical styling in modern sizes and widths that actual vintage shoes rarely come in.
• Expression: Vintage-style footwear allows you to express appreciation for historical fashion while maintaining practicality.

FAQs

Are vintage-style shoes comfortable for everyday wear?

Yes, many modern vintage-inspired shoes incorporate comfort features while maintaining period aesthetics. Brands like Charlie Stone and Eastland particularly focus on comfort.

What is the difference between saddle shoes and oxfords?

Saddle shoes are a type of oxford featuring a saddle-shaped panel in a contrasting color across the middle. All saddle shoes are oxfords, but not all oxfords are saddle shoes.

How do I know what size to order?

Always check the brand’s specific size chart and read reviews about fit. Many vintage-inspired shoes use different sizing standards than modern footwear.

Can vintage-style leather shoes be worn in rain?

Leather shoes with rubber soles can handle light rain if properly treated with water-repellent spray. However, leather-soled shoes should be avoided in wet conditions.

Are there vegan alternatives to leather vintage-style shoes?

Yes, brands like Ellie Shoes offer synthetic alternatives that mimic vintage styles without using animal products.

How do I break in stiff leather vintage-style shoes?

Wear them for short periods initially, using thick socks. Some people use a leather conditioner to soften stiff areas. Never use direct heat to speed up breaking in.

Can I replace the soles on my vintage-style shoes?

Yes, most quality vintage-inspired shoes can have their soles replaced by a professional cobbler when they wear out.

What outfits work best with vintage-style shoes?

Vintage-style shoes pair beautifully with period-appropriate clothing but also work well with modern basics like jeans, trousers, and simple dresses for a touch of retro flair.