10 Best Alternatives To Taft Boots: Superior Style, Comfort & Durability

Are you searching for stylish boots with the same premium quality as Taft but want to explore other options? u’re in the right place.

Taft boots have gained popularity for their unique designs and excellent craftsmanship, but there are several worthy alternatives that deserve your attention.

This guide will help you discover the 10 best alternatives to Taft boots that offer impressive style, exceptional comfort, and remarkable durability. These boots provide similar or even better quality while catering to different preferences and budgets.

Key Takeaways

• Thursday Boot Company offers excellent value with Goodyear welt construction and premium leathers at a more accessible price point than Taft.
• Grant Stone provides superior construction quality with Horween leathers and exceptional attention to detail, widely considered better value than many American-made competitors.
• Red Wing boots feature legendary durability with thick, full-grain leathers that develop beautiful patinas over time.
• Jim Green offers rugged outdoor performance with water-resistant full-grain leather and specialized soles for different terrains.
• Parkhurst creates American-made boots with unique leathers and solid construction at competitive prices.
• Beckett Simonon uses a made-to-order model resulting in high-quality boots at lower prices due to reduced inventory costs.
• Helm boots feature distinctive white midsoles and hybrid construction methods balancing weight and durability.
• Golden Fox provides budget-friendly options with Goodyear welt construction at significantly lower prices.
• Meermin offers European craftsmanship with sleek designs and exceptional value for money.
• Clarks delivers classic desert boot styling with immediate comfort and versatility at affordable prices.
• Most alternatives feature resoleable construction for extended life, making them smart long-term investments.
• Price ranges vary widely from budget options around $80 to premium choices over $400, offering something for every budget.

Thursday Boot Company Captain Boots

The Thursday Boot Company Captain boots represent one of the most popular alternatives to Taft boots. These boots have gained a strong following for good reasons. The Captain features a sleek cap-toe design that works well in both casual and semi-formal settings.

Thursday uses premium full-grain leather from respected tanneries which develops a beautiful patina over time. The interior features a cork-bed midsole that conforms to your foot with wear, creating a custom fit. The boots use Goodyear welt construction, making them water-resistant and resoleable when the time comes.

Pros:

• Exceptional value at $199
• Goodyear welt construction
• Comfortable right out of the box
• Available in many leather options
• Robust leather build with minimal break-in

Cons:

• Some quality control issues reported
• Not as unique as some Taft designs
• Limited width options

The Thursday Captain boots offer remarkable versatility. The clean design looks great with jeans and can even work with business casual outfits. The studded rubber outsoles provide good traction while maintaining a relatively sleek profile.

Grant Stone Diesel Boots

Grant Stone has established itself as a premium boot maker offering exceptional value. Their Diesel Boot model is widely regarded as one of the best values in quality footwear. These boots feature immaculate construction that rivals brands costing twice as much.

The Diesel Boot uses Horween Chromexcel leather, known for its rich depth, pull-up character, and durability. The boots are built on the Leo last, which provides excellent support and a comfortable fit. Grant Stone’s attention to detail is evident in the perfect stitching, brass eyelets, and vegetable-tanned leather insoles.

Pros:

• Superior construction quality
• Horween leather options
• Full leather lining
• Vegetable-tanned leather insoles
• Excellent arch support

Cons:

• Higher price point ($350-435)
• Limited retail availability (mostly online)
• Heavier than some competitors

Grant Stone focuses on doing the basics exceptionally well rather than creating bold, unique designs. The result is a boot that feels substantial and well-made from the moment you pick it up. The clean, timeless design will remain in style for years to come.

Red Wing Iron Ranger Boots

Red Wing’s Iron Ranger boots have achieved legendary status among boot enthusiasts. Made in the USA since 1905, Red Wing has perfected their craft over generations. The Iron Ranger features a distinctive cap-toe design with a sleek profile despite its robust construction.

The full-grain leather used in these boots is exceptionally thick and durable. Red Wing’s proprietary leathers develop rich patinas over time that tell the story of your adventures. The double-layer leather toe cap provides extra protection, while the Vibram mini-lug sole offers excellent traction.

Pros:

• Legendary durability
• Made in USA heritage
• Develops beautiful patina
• Proven design since 1905
• Excellent resale value

Cons:

• Significant break-in period
• Less cushioning than some alternatives
• Limited style options

Red Wing boots are built to last decades with proper care. They represent an investment in quality that pays dividends over time. The Iron Ranger combines classic styling with bombproof construction that can handle anything from city streets to light hiking.

Jim Green African Ranger Boots

Jim Green boots represent an excellent value in rugged outdoor footwear. The African Ranger model, made in South Africa, offers exceptional performance for work and outdoor activities. These boots feature water-resistant full-grain leather uppers with a comfortable design inspired by African wilderness guides.

The boots include ankle padding for greater comfort and protection on rough terrain. The specialized wedge sole is designed for excellent grip while remaining quiet during walking, making them ideal for hiking and outdoor adventures. Jim Green’s construction quality rivals boots costing significantly more.

Pros:

• Outstanding value at around $190
• Water-resistant full-grain leather
• Comfortable padded ankle design
• Quiet but grippy sole design
• Excellent for outdoor activities

Cons:

• Less refined for formal settings
• Limited availability in physical stores
• Fewer style options than some brands

Jim Green boots offer exceptional performance for outdoor enthusiasts and workers who need dependable footwear. The rugged construction means they can handle demanding conditions while remaining comfortable for all-day wear.

Parkhurst Allen Boots

Parkhurst has gained a loyal following for creating high-quality, American-made boots at competitive prices. The Allen boot is their flagship model, featuring a versatile design that works well in various settings. These boots are handcrafted in Western New York with meticulous attention to detail.

Parkhurst often uses unique leathers from renowned tanneries like Horween, C.F. Stead, and Seidel. The Allen boot features a Goodyear welt construction with a steel shank for stability and support. The Vibram lug soles provide excellent traction in all conditions while maintaining a relatively sleek profile.

Pros:

• American-made craftsmanship
• Unique, high-quality leathers
• Excellent construction
• Good value at around $350-420
• Superior customer service

Cons:

• Limited production capacity
• Fewer style options than larger brands
• Sometimes sell out of popular sizes

Parkhurst boots represent an excellent option for those who appreciate American craftsmanship and unique leathers. The Allen boot strikes a good balance between rugged construction and refined styling, making it versatile for many occasions.

Beckett Simonon Bolton Chelsea Boots

No products found.

Beckett Simonon uses a made-to-order model that allows them to offer exceptional quality at lower prices. Their Bolton Chelsea Boots represent an excellent alternative to Taft’s Chelsea models. These boots feature clean lines and a versatile design suitable for both casual and formal settings.

The full-grain leather uppers come from ethical, Gold-rated tanneries. The boots are handcrafted in small batches by experienced artisans in Colombia. The Blake stitch construction makes them lightweight and flexible while still being resoleable. The leather lining and insole increase comfort and breathability.

Pros:

• Excellent value at around $200-269
• Ethically sourced materials
• Comfortable from first wear
• Elegant, versatile design
• Available in many leather options

Cons:

• Wait time for production (6-8 weeks)
• No physical stores for trying on
• Limited width options

Beckett Simonon’s business model eliminates unnecessary markups, resulting in high-quality boots at accessible prices. The Bolton Chelsea boots offer refined styling and quality construction that compares favorably with boots costing significantly more.

Helm Zind Boots

Helm boots offer distinctive styling that stands out from the crowd. The Zind model features their signature white midsole that creates a striking visual contrast with the upper leather. These boots are designed in Texas and handcrafted by skilled artisans using premium materials.

Helm uses a unique “Fineline” sole that provides excellent grip while maintaining a dressy profile. The boots feature a Blake Rapid construction that balances lightweight comfort with durability. The 415 last gives the Zind a narrow, refined shape that works well with dressier outfits.

Pros:

• Distinctive white midsole design
• Lightweight yet durable
• Versatile style range
• Quality leathers
• Blake Rapid construction

Cons:

• Higher price point ($295)
• Limited width availability
• Mixed reviews on sizing

Helm boots offer something different for those who want quality construction but don’t want their boots to look like everyone else’s. The white midsole creates a visual signature that’s instantly recognizable while not being overly flashy.

Golden Fox Boondocker Service Boots

Golden Fox offers some of the best value in Goodyear welted boots. Their Boondocker Service Boot provides impressive quality at a fraction of the price of other brands on this list. These boots feature a simple, clean design inspired by military service boots.

The oil-resistant Goodyear welt construction ensures these boots can be resoled, extending their life for years. The leather is surprisingly good quality for the price point, developing character with wear. The cushioned insole provides comfort right out of the box with minimal break-in required.

Pros:

• Exceptional value at around $80
• Goodyear welt construction
• Comfortable cushioned insole
• Minimal break-in period
• Classic, versatile styling

Cons:

• Lower grade leather than premium brands
• Less refined finishing details
• Limited color options

Golden Fox Boondockers represent an excellent entry point for those wanting quality construction without spending hundreds of dollars. They offer 80% of the quality of boots costing three times as much, making them an outstanding value proposition.

Meermin Chestnut Country Calf Boots

Meermin offers European craftsmanship at prices that rival American brands. Their Chestnut Country Calf boots feature distinctive pebble grain leather with rich color and texture. Made in Spain with traditional methods, these boots represent exceptional value.

Meermin uses Goodyear welt construction with oak-tanned leather insoles and cork filling that molds to your foot over time. The boots feature a sleek European last shape that’s slightly dressier than American workwear-inspired designs. The Dainite-style studded rubber soles provide good traction while maintaining a clean profile.

Pros:

• European craftsmanship
• Sleek, elegant design
• Quality construction methods
• Excellent leather selection
• Great value at around $250

Cons:

• Significant break-in period
• Shipping from Spain (potential import duties)
• Limited customer service availability

Meermin boots offer exceptional value for those seeking a more European aesthetic. The sleeker last shape and refined details make these boots suitable for dressier occasions while maintaining durability for everyday wear.

Clarks Bushacre Boots

Clarks Bushacre boots represent the most affordable option on our list while still offering good quality and classic styling. Based on the iconic Desert Boot design, the Bushacre features clean lines and minimalist construction that has remained popular for decades.

The suede or leather uppers age beautifully with wear. The synthetic rubber sole offers better durability than the crepe sole found on the original Desert Boot. The simple two-eyelet design makes these boots easy to put on and take off, while the unlined interior molds to your foot over time.

Pros:

• Excellent value at around $45-60
• Comfortable from first wear
• Timeless design
• Versatile styling options
• Widely available for trying on

Cons:

• Not resoleable
• Less durable than Goodyear welted options
• Limited support and cushioning

Clarks Bushacres offer classic chukka boot styling at an accessible price point. While they won’t last as long as the Goodyear welted options on this list, they provide excellent value and immediate comfort for those on a budget.

SUREWAY Captain Boots

SUREWAY offers an affordable alternative to Thursday’s Captain boots with similar styling at a lower price point. These cap-toe boots feature genuine leather uppers and a comfortable design that works well for everyday wear. The classic styling makes them versatile for various outfits and occasions.

The boots feature a comfortable insole and breathable lining that helps prevent foot odor. The rubber outsole provides good traction on various surfaces. While not Goodyear welted like premium options, they offer good value for those seeking the aesthetic of a cap-toe service boot without the higher investment.

Pros:

• Budget-friendly at around $125
• Classic cap-toe styling
• Comfortable insole
• Multiple color options
• Good customer reviews

Cons:

• Simpler construction than premium options
• Less durable long-term
• May not be resoleable

SUREWAY Captain boots represent a good entry point for those exploring quality footwear without making a significant investment. They offer the look of more expensive boots at an accessible price point.

Arkbird Oxford Dress Boots

Arkbird offers stylish dress boots at very competitive prices. Their Oxford Dress Boots feature classic styling with modern comfort features. The genuine leather uppers develop character over time while maintaining a refined appearance suitable for more formal settings.

These boots include cushioned insoles and breathable linings for all-day comfort. The side zipper makes them easy to put on and take off while maintaining a clean aesthetic. The rubber outsole provides good traction while maintaining a low profile appropriate for dressier occasions.

Pros:

• Very affordable at around $70
• Classic styling
• Side zipper for convenience
• Comfortable cushioned insole
• Good for dressier occasions

Cons:

• Simpler construction than premium brands
• Less durable long-term
• Limited color options

Arkbird Oxford Dress Boots provide an affordable option for those needing a dressier boot without making a major investment. They work well for occasional wear or as an entry point into quality footwear.

How To Choose The Right Taft Boot Alternative

When selecting an alternative to Taft boots, consider these important factors:

1. Construction Method: Goodyear welt construction offers the best durability and resolability, while Blake stitch provides more flexibility with a sleeker profile.
2. Leather Quality: Full-grain leather offers the best durability and develops character over time. Look for leather from renowned tanneries like Horween for the best quality.
3. Fit and Sizing: Many boot brands size differently. Check sizing guides and reviews to determine if you should size down or stay true to size.
4. Intended Use: Consider where you’ll wear the boots most often. Some options are better suited for outdoor activities, while others work better in office settings.
5. Budget: Quality boots are an investment. While higher-priced options often offer better materials and construction, brands like Golden Fox prove you can find good quality at lower price points.
6. Style Preferences: Boots range from sleek, dressy designs to rugged work styles. Choose a design that complements your wardrobe and personal aesthetic.

Remember that quality boots often require a break-in period to conform to your feet, but this results in superior comfort long-term.

What Sets These Alternatives Apart From Taft Boots?

While Taft boots are known for bold designs and unique materials, these alternatives often focus on different strengths:

1. Construction Quality: Brands like Grant Stone often provide superior construction compared to Taft at similar price points.
2. Heritage: Companies like Red Wing offer decades or even centuries of bootmaking experience and proven designs.
3. Value Proposition: Many alternatives like Thursday Boot Company and Golden Fox provide excellent value by focusing on essential quality elements while trimming unnecessary costs.
4. Made in USA Options: Parkhurst, Red Wing, and some other alternatives offer American-made boots for those prioritizing domestic manufacturing.
5. Classic Designs: While Taft often creates bold, fashion-forward styles, many alternatives focus on perfecting timeless designs that remain relevant for decades.

Each brand has its own philosophy and priorities, allowing you to find the perfect match for your specific needs and preferences.

How To Care For Your Quality Boots

Proper care significantly extends the life of your investment-grade footwear:

1. Regular Cleaning: Wipe boots with a damp cloth to remove dirt and salt. Use a soft brush for suede.
2. Conditioning: Apply leather conditioner every few months to keep leather supple and prevent cracking. Brands like Venetian Shoe Cream, Bick 4, and Saphir are excellent options.
3. Shoe Trees: Cedar shoe trees absorb moisture and help boots maintain their shape. Insert them whenever you’re not wearing your boots.
4. Rotation: Avoid wearing the same pair daily. Leather needs 24-48 hours to dry completely between wears.
5. Weather Protection: Apply a water-resistant treatment to protect against rain and snow. Specific products are available for different leather types.
6. Resoling: When the soles wear down, have Goodyear welted boots resoled rather than replacing them. This extends their life for many years.

With proper care, quality boots can last a decade or longer, making them a smart investment despite the higher initial cost.

FAQs

How do Taft boots compare to Thursday boots?

Thursday boots generally offer better value with similar construction quality at a lower price point. Taft boots typically feature more unique designs and exotic materials but cost significantly more. Thursday boots are often more comfortable right out of the box.

Are Grant Stone boots worth the price?

Yes. Grant Stone boots offer exceptional value with construction quality that rivals brands costing twice as much. Their attention to detail, quality materials, and perfect finishing make them worth the investment.

Do Red Wing boots run true to size?

No. Most people need to size down a half to full size in Red Wing boots. Try them on in person if possible or check the specific model’s sizing recommendations before ordering.

Which boots require the least break-in time?

Thursday Boot Company, Beckett Simonon, and Clarks generally require minimal break-in time. Red Wing and Meermin typically need more extensive breaking in before reaching maximum comfort.

Are Goodyear welted boots worth the extra cost?

Yes. Goodyear welt construction allows boots to be resoled multiple times, extending their life significantly. This makes them more economical long-term despite higher initial costs.

How long should quality boots last?

With proper care and occasional resoling, high-quality Goodyear welted boots can last 5-10 years or more of regular wear. Some Red Wing boots have been known to last decades with proper maintenance.

Can I wear these boots in rain and snow?

Most Goodyear welted boots offer good water resistance, especially after applying appropriate weather protection products. However, for frequent exposure to harsh elements, look for specifically designed waterproof options.

Which boots offer the best value for money?

Golden Fox offers exceptional value at the lower price range, while Thursday Boot Company provides excellent value in the mid-range. Grant Stone represents outstanding value in the premium category despite their higherprice point.