Tulsa Body Jewelry Review: Quality, Selection, and Customer Experience

Are you looking for high-quality body jewelry that combines style, comfort, and affordability? Tulsa Body Jewelry has established itself as a go-to destination for body modification enthusiasts across the country.

This Tulsa-based retailer offers an extensive selection of body jewelry ranging from basic studs to elaborate custom designs.

Founded in the early 2000s, Tulsa Body Jewelry has been serving customers both online since 2002 and through their physical store in Tulsa, Oklahoma since 2006.

Key Takeaways

• Extensive Product Range: Tulsa Body Jewelry offers everything from 20 gauge to 3-inch sizes, covering all common body piercing types and stretched ear needs
• Material Variety: Their inventory includes jewelry made from stainless steel, titanium, stone, glass, wood, bone, and horn, giving customers plenty of options based on sensitivity and style preferences
• Physical and Online Presence: Operating both a brick-and-mortar store in Tulsa and a comprehensive online shop makes them accessible to local and national customers
• Competitive Pricing: Their products are generally more affordable than many specialized piercing shops while maintaining acceptable quality standards
• Free Shipping: Orders over $25 qualify for free shipping, adding value for online shoppers
• Specialized Jewelry: They offer hard-to-find sizes and styles that aren’t commonly available at general retailers
• Mixed Reviews: Customer feedback varies from extremely positive regarding selection and staff to some concerns about specific product quality
• Material Education: Their website provides detailed information about jewelry materials and their properties, helping customers make informed decisions
• Established History: With over 20 years in the business, they have built a reputation in the body jewelry industry
• Loyalty Program: They offer a rewards system for repeat customers, encouraging return business
• Local Curbside Pickup: Convenient same-day pickup service for local customers provides an added convenience factor

The History and Evolution of Tulsa Body Jewelry

Tulsa Body Jewelry has a rich history in the body modification community. The company began its journey in 2002 as an online retailer, recognizing the growing demand for quality body jewelry at reasonable prices.

Four years later, in January 2006, they expanded their operation by opening a physical store in Tulsa, Oklahoma. This strategic move allowed them to better serve local customers while maintaining their online presence for nationwide reach.

The shop is conveniently located in midtown Tulsa, just north of the intersection at 19th Street and South Harvard Avenue. Over the years, they have built a reputation for offering an extensive range of products catering to various body modification needs.

The physical store operates with business hours from Monday to Saturday, 9 AM to 5 PM, allowing customers to browse their collection and receive personalized assistance from knowledgeable staff members.

Extensive Product Range: Something for Everyone

Tulsa Body Jewelry truly stands out with its impressive product selection that caters to virtually every type of body modification. Their inventory covers the full spectrum of gauge sizes, from the smallest 20 gauge all the way up to an impressive 3 inches, ensuring that customers of all piercing and stretching levels can find exactly what they need.

Their product categories include:

• Belly Jewelry: A vast collection including dangles, non-dangles, clickers, and reverse belly rings for navel piercings
• Cartilage Jewelry: Specialized pieces for various ear cartilage piercings including cuffs, dangles, rings, and studs
• Plugs and Tunnels: An extensive selection for stretched ears in various materials, shapes, and designs
• Nostril Jewelry: Options including L-bend studs, nose bones, hoops, screws, unbent pins, and retainers
• Septum Jewelry: Specialized pieces including clickers, pincers, retainers, and tusks
• Tongue Barbells: Various styles and materials for tongue piercings
• Labret Jewelry: Versatile options for lip and under-lip piercings

What makes their collection truly remarkable is the variety of specialized items that can be difficult to find elsewhere. They stock jewelry for less common piercings such as bridge, cheek, anti-eyebrow, and various intimate piercings.

This comprehensive approach ensures that customers with unique or multiple piercings can fulfill all their jewelry needs in one place.

Additionally, they offer essential accessories like piercing tools, replacement parts, chains, and o-rings, making them a one-stop shop for body modification enthusiasts. Whether you’re looking for basic jewelry or statement pieces, Tulsa Body Jewelry likely has options to match your style and requirements.

Quality Materials: Understanding What You’re Buying

Tulsa Body Jewelry demonstrates a strong commitment to material education by providing detailed information about the various metals and substances used in their products. This transparency helps customers make informed decisions based on their specific needs and sensitivities.

Their stainless steel jewelry primarily uses 316L grade, which is suitable for most wearers but does contain small amounts of nickel. For customers with nickel sensitivity, they clearly recommend alternatives like titanium and solid 14k gold. This honesty about potential allergens shows their concern for customer well-being rather than just making a sale.

For those interested in colored jewelry, approximately 90% of their colored titanium pieces are anodized in-house. They even explain the science behind the anodization process, describing how it creates an oxide layer that produces color through light interference rather than using dyes. This attention to detail demonstrates their technical knowledge and commitment to quality.

Their glass jewelry comes in both hard borosilicate (Pyrex) and soft soda-lime varieties, with clear explanations about the differences in durability and properties. They’re transparent about natural variations in hand-carved organic materials like wood, bone, and horn, setting appropriate expectations for customers ordering these items.

The website also provides candid information about acrylic jewelry, acknowledging its limitations including being unsuitable for initial piercings, not autoclavable, and not recommended for long-term wear. This level of honesty about a popular but potentially problematic material reflects their ethical approach to business.

Additionally, they offer comprehensive guidance on internal versus external threading, explaining the benefits and drawbacks of each option. Their detailed sizing charts and measuring guides further help customers select the right jewelry for their specific piercings.

Shopping Experience: Online and In-Store Options

Tulsa Body Jewelry offers customers a flexible shopping experience through both their physical store and comprehensive online platform. This dual approach caters to different shopping preferences and needs, making their products accessible to a wider audience.

The physical store in Tulsa provides a traditional retail experience where customers can see and touch the jewelry before purchasing. Located at 1742 South Harvard Avenue, the shop has a helpful staff ready to answer questions and provide personalized recommendations based on individual needs.

Many customers appreciate the opportunity to receive immediate assistance with sizing and material selection, particularly for more complex piercings.

Their online store at tulsabodyjewelry.com offers a user-friendly interface with detailed product categories and filtering options. The website is well-organized, allowing customers to browse by jewelry type, piercing location, material, or gauge size.

Each product listing includes comprehensive information about specifications, materials, and care instructions, helping online shoppers make informed decisions.

Price Points: Value for Money Analysis

Tulsa Body Jewelry positions itself in an interesting spot in the market when it comes to pricing. They operate in what could be described as the mid-range pricing tier of the body jewelry market, striking a balance between mass-produced budget items and high-end designer pieces.

Their stainless steel basic jewelry starts at very affordable prices, with simple pieces like plain barbells and rings available for under $10. This makes them accessible to beginners or those on tight budgets. Their titanium pieces, which offer better biocompatibility for sensitive individuals, are priced higher but still remain more affordable than many specialty piercing shops.

When comparing with competitors, Tulsa Body Jewelry generally offers:

• More competitive pricing than professional piercing studios that typically mark up jewelry significantly
• Higher prices than generic online retailers selling mass-produced items of questionable quality
• Lower prices than designer body jewelry brands focused on the luxury market

The company offers free shipping on orders exceeding $25, which adds value and effectively reduces the overall cost for customers making moderate purchases. This policy encourages slightly larger orders while providing a tangible benefit to online shoppers.

What stands out about their pricing structure is the wide range available within each category. For example, in their plugs collection, customers can find basic options for around $15-20 per pair, while premium materials like genuine stone or intricate designs might range from $50-100. This tiered approach allows customers with different budgets to find options within the same store.

Customer Service: Support and Satisfaction

The customer service experience at Tulsa Body Jewelry appears to be generally positive, though with some mixed feedback depending on the platform and individual experiences. Their approach to customer support spans multiple channels, making it accessible for different types of customers.

For in-store visitors, many reviews highlight the knowledgeable and friendly staff who provide personalized recommendations and answers to technical questions about materials, sizing, and piercing care. Several customers specifically mention staff members by name, suggesting memorable positive interactions.

The store environment is described as welcoming and non-judgmental, which is particularly important in the body modification community where customers may have varying levels of experience.

Online customers can reach the support team through multiple channels:

• Email support via help@tulsabodyjewelry.com
• Phone assistance at 918.888.8880
• Social media messaging on platforms like Facebook and Instagram
• Their website’s help section with extensive FAQs

Response times appear to be relatively prompt for online inquiries, with most customers receiving replies within 1-2 business days. For telephone support, the company operates during their regular business hours of Monday through Saturday, 9 AM to 5 PM Central Time.

Their shipping policies are clear and straightforward, with most orders shipping within two business days. The free shipping on orders over $25 is frequently mentioned as a positive aspect of their service. For issues like sizing problems or defective items, customers report a generally fair return process, though some reviews mention difficulties with certain return situations.

Online Reputation: What Customers Are Saying

Tulsa Body Jewelry has established a significant online presence with thousands of reviews across various platforms. These reviews provide valuable insights into the real customer experience beyond marketing claims. The feedback reveals both consistent strengths and some areas where experiences vary considerably.

On their Facebook page, which has over 19,500 likes and followers, the company maintains a strong rating with numerous positive testimonials. Customers frequently praise the shop’s extensive selection and helpful staff who provide personalized recommendations. Many reviewers mention returning to the store repeatedly over several years, indicating strong customer loyalty.

Yelp reviews for the physical store location show a more mixed picture, with an overall rating that hovers around 3.8 stars. Positive reviews highlight the knowledgeable employees and competitive pricing, while critical reviews occasionally mention concerns about jewelry quality or durability issues with certain items.

Trustpilot reviews show a lower overall rating of approximately 2.4 stars from a limited number of reviews. These reviews tend to focus more on online ordering experiences, with some customers reporting issues with sizing accuracy or shipping concerns.

Common themes across positive reviews include:

• Appreciation for the wide selection of sizes and styles
• Satisfaction with the quality-to-price ratio
• Positive experiences with the in-store staff
• Fast shipping for online orders

Recurring concerns in critical reviews involve:

• Questions about the actual materials used in some lower-priced items
• Sizing inconsistencies between ordered and received items
• Customer service responses to problems with online orders

It’s worth noting that the company actively responds to many reviews, both positive and negative, demonstrating engagement with customer feedback. Their responses typically offer solutions to resolve issues, showing a commitment to customer satisfaction even when problems arise.

Materials Guide: Making the Right Choice for Your Body

Selecting the appropriate material for body jewelry is crucial for comfort, healing, and preventing adverse reactions. Tulsa Body Jewelry offers various material options, each with distinct properties suitable for different situations and sensitivity levels.

Stainless Steel (316L) is one of their most popular and affordable options. This material is durable and resistant to tarnishing, making it a practical choice for everyday wear. However, it contains small amounts of nickel, which may cause reactions in sensitive individuals.

Tulsa Body Jewelry honestly acknowledges this limitation rather than making false claims about their stainless steel being completely nickel-free. This material is best suited for healed piercings in people without metal sensitivities.

Titanium represents a premium alternative that is fully biocompatible and nickel-free. Tulsa Body Jewelry offers both plain titanium and anodized options in various colors, with most of their colored titanium being anodized in-house.

The anodization process creates colors through an oxide layer rather than dyes, maintaining the metal’s biocompatibility. Titanium is ideal for initial piercings, sensitive skin, and long-term wear despite its higher price point compared to steel.

Customization and Unique Offerings

Tulsa Body Jewelry distinguishes itself through several unique offerings and specialized products that set them apart from standard body jewelry retailers. While they don’t focus heavily on custom-made pieces, they excel in providing hard-to-find sizes, materials, and specialized jewelry types that appeal to more experienced body modification enthusiasts.

One of their standout features is their extensive range of gauge sizes, spanning from standard 20 gauge all the way to an impressive 3 inches. This comprehensive sizing makes them particularly valuable for individuals with stretched piercings who often struggle to find properly sized jewelry in conventional stores.

Their inventory includes numerous options even in the larger, less common sizes that many retailers don’t stock.

Comparing with Competitors: How Does Tulsa Body Jewelry Stack Up?

The body jewelry market includes various types of retailers, from mass-market websites to high-end boutiques. Understanding how Tulsa Body Jewelry compares to these competitors provides valuable context for potential customers.

When compared to mainstream online retailers like Amazon or eBay, Tulsa Body Jewelry offers significantly better product knowledge and specialization. While these general marketplaces may have lower prices on basic items, they typically lack verification of material quality and proper sizing.

Tulsa Body Jewelry provides detailed material information and sizing guides that these mass-market platforms rarely offer. However, shipping times may be longer than Amazon’s rapid delivery service.

Against specialized online competitors like Bodyartforms and Urban Body Jewelry, Tulsa Body Jewelry holds its own in terms of selection and pricing. Their product range is comparable, with all three offering extensive options across various jewelry types and materials.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Tulsa Body Jewelry good quality?

Tulsa Body Jewelry offers variable quality depending on the materials and price point. Their titanium and glass products receive consistently good reviews, while some of their more budget-friendly options may have occasional quality issues. Most customers report satisfactory experiences with their mid-range products.

Does Tulsa Body Jewelry use real materials as advertised?

Yes, evidence suggests they use genuine materials as described. They have even sent products for laboratory testing when questions arose about authenticity. Their detailed material descriptions and honest explanations about limitations suggest transparency about product composition.

How long does shipping take from Tulsa Body Jewelry?

Most orders ship within 2 business days according to their website. Delivery times vary based on location, but domestic orders typically arrive within 3-7 business days after shipping. They offer free shipping on orders over $25.

Can I return jewelry if it doesn’t fit?

Tulsa Body Jewelry does accept returns for sizing issues, though specific policies may apply. Customers should contact them promptly if there are fit problems. Custom or specialty items may have different return restrictions.

Does Tulsa Body Jewelry offer any guarantees?

They guarantee the materials of their products will be as advertised. For natural materials like stone, wood, and horn, they note that color and pattern variations are normal and to be expected. They also guarantee matching pairs for items sold as pairs.

Is their jewelry safe for sensitive skin?

For sensitive skin, their titanium and glass options are recommended over stainless steel, which contains small amounts of nickel. They are transparent about potential allergens in different materials, allowing customers to make informed choices.